The massive international demonstration for women on Jan. 21 and the generous response of so many Americans to the ban on predominantly Muslim countries are signs of a democratic and civic awakening that can only give us heart. However, I think it’s a bit excessive to euphorically declare that “America rebels against Trump.”
After all, Trump is doing exactly what voters asked him to do, and I doubt many of them are changing their minds, especially now that they see he delivers on his promises. When Barack Obama said that the actions of the new president endanger the values of the United States, he’s partly right and partly not. The part of America that allowed the rise of Trump certainly hasn’t disappeared. And Trump isn’t a monster that came out of nowhere; he’s one part of an American history that has been both welcoming to immigrants but also chauvinistic and xenophobic. America is a constant tension between these two modes.
The brutality and speed of Trump’s incompetent action is certainly a dramatic shift from precedent, but I do not view it as a rare departure from the American values practiced for centuries. Recall the nativist movements in the mid 1800s, when anti-Catholic citizens rampaged against Irish immigration. Recall the Chinese Exclusion Act of 1882 and the 1920s quota policy that drastically reduced admissions from countries deemed less desirable, including Italy. There was the Japanese immigration ban of 1924, the refusal to admit boatloads of Jewish refugees in 1939, the concentration camps for American citizens of Japanese (and also of Italian) ancestry during World War II and, of course, the persistence of racial segregation in the South until the 1960s.